NJBMS - Volume 7, Issue 2, October - December 2016

Pages: 106-112

Comparison Of Phenotypic And Genotypic Methods For The Detection Of Imipenem Resistant Enterobacteriaceae Isolates

Author: C.Anuradha, S .Mathavi, R.Indra Priyadharsini,

Category: Microbiology

[Download PDF]


INTRODUCTION : The rapid spread of metallobetalactamases (MBL) is a diagnostic challenge in clinical microbiology as there are concerns regarding the reliability of the various phenotypic detection methods.

AIMS AND OBJECTIVES : To assess the efficiency of the phenotypic assays namely the combined disc test (CDT), double disc synergy test (DDST) and the MBL E test as compared to PCR for the detection of MBLs in enterobacteriaceae.

MATERIALS AND METHODS: Two hundred and four non-repetitive enterobacteriaceae isolates from clinical samples from October 2013 to September 2014 were included in the study.Isolates that showed a resistant zone ( ≤ 19 mm ) to imipenem were screened by means of combined disc test (CDT), double disc synergy test (DDST) and E test (imipenem/imipenem+EDTA E strips, Biomeriuex). Multiplex PCR was done to confirm the presence of MBLgenes.

RESULTS : The study showed 49 isolates resistant to imipenem, of which 12 ( 24.48% ) were positive for MBL production by both combined and double disc methods; 37 ( 75.52% ) showed positivity by combined disc only and 12 ( 24.48% )isolates by double disc method only.Twelve isolates showed a MIC of ≥4µg/mLby E test .PCR detected genes in 11 isolates(22.4%) only.

CONCLUSION : Since phenotypic methods give variable results, it is not advisable to employ a single screening criterion for carbapenemase detection.Phenotypic methods though specific, do not differentiate between chromosomal and plasmid encoded genes and hence genotypic characterization ( PCR ) should be considered.

Keywords: Phenotypic methods, genotypic methods, Imipenem, Enterobacteriaceae

No. of online users: 59

Search Articles

Visitor Counter

World wide visitors


Editor in Chief of NJBMS Dr.Deepti Shastri, Professor and Head, Department of Anatomy, Academic Co-ordinator for Pre and Paraclinical Sciences, VMKV Medical College & Hospital, Salem.

Indexed in

Index Copernicus (MCI recognized indexing body) ICV - 75.97, Scientific Indexing Services, Research Bib, Indian Science Publication, Eurasian Scientific Journal Index, Science Library Index, International Innovative Journal Impact Factor, Cite Factor, International Impact Factor Service,

Publication Statistics

Articles Statistics


Society for Basic Medical Sciences
NJBMS Journal - Indexed in Index Copernicus

Manuscript Statistics

Subscribe for TOC Alerts

Get the table of contents of current issues.

E-mail Alerts